Tuesday, June 12, 2012

Going Long


I don’t write short stories.

Make that can’t write short stories.

My first-ever GIF on the blog!
OK, maybe if I really worked at it and went off on a spiritual quest and spent 40 days in the desert covered in dried mud, channeling my animal spirit guide, and then came home and did a lot of core muscle training with one of those exercise ball thingies…MAYBE I could learn to write a halfway decent short story. But I don’t see myself doing that at this late stage in the game. And I detest doing sit-ups, so really it’s a non-starter.

I’m going to tell you an extremely embarrassing thing about my first YA manuscript, and you are going to howl with derisive laughter, and then I’m going to pout because it’s not nice to do that to someone who’s in confession mode. But I’m going to tell you anyway because I need to get it off my chest.

My first YA manuscript was 185,000 words long.

And I queried that mutha with a straight face.

Yes. OK. I totally deserved that buwahahahaha. Time for a musical interlude. Please watch this while you get control of yourself.   


Writing short or even shortish is hard work for me. (See previous post on being an overthinkerer.) I think I would have done well in the 19th century. When real men wrote manly books, and by God, girth counted for something! People didn’t mind a few digressions on whaling and such back then. No, they did not.

Nowadays? No. Writing long is not a bonus. I’m sure that not being able to write short is the reason I bombed out as a journalist.

Each of us has a natural writing distance that’s most comfortable. Some people are pithy as heck. Their tweets are funny and meaningful; they sound like Mark Twain writing fortune cookie fortunes. Other people write hilarious blog posts that hit just the right spot lengthwise and make people inclined to visit again and again.

Not me.

If left unchecked, I would specialize in bloat.

So, yeah, I’m doing my best to keep things brief, and blogging has helped me get the verbiage under control, but I recognize that there’s a level of shortness beyond which I cannot hope to go. Short stories will never be an area of writing strength for me. Frankly, I can hardly even sign a check without adding a footnote. 

Anyone else out there like me, pressing acres of words down into a single bottle of prose? I’m thinking there must be a vitamin supplement that can help me. Maybe a vaccine. Something like that?

Comments (9)

Loading... Logging you in...
  • Logged in as
I'm thinking supplements might not be the best idea - I mean don't they make you sort of uber everything you already are. Can you imagine the ms length if you were taking supplements?

But, honey! I am impressed. I think I'd blow up if I wrote 185k all in one little ole' manuscript. We won't talk about that query episode ;0)
1 reply · active 669 weeks ago
I appreciate your discretion. A 185K ms is easier to write than you might think. You just make the fundamental mistake of including every damn thing. Voila! Bloat.
"When real men wrote manly books, and by God, girth counted for something! People didn’t mind a few digressions on whaling and such back then." Bwa-ha-ha-ha!!!

I'm with you! My first drafts are full of bloat and digressions and filler and plot threads I might need later so I better stick them in while I can ...

My current YA WIP is at 70k and I think it's only 2/3 to 3/4 done. I can't tell for sure. I only know that I will need a scythe to cut it down in the second draft. Or maybe an industrial strength chain saw.
1 reply · active 669 weeks ago
On the plus side, cutting is waaaay easier than filling in, right? So we've got that going for us.

When you rent the chain saw, see if you can get one with a diamond-encrusted cutting blade. They work the best.
Clicking on the post title is a giant PITA. ANYHOO, I've written a few short stories in my time, but I don't much like the format, nor do I much care for reading them. They're just too narrow for my taste. And in writing, like you, I needs room to maneuver.
I don't think I could put 185,000 words together if I were copying the dictionary. I'm too afraid I'll veer off point and never make it back. Kudos to you...and stronger coffee to all those reading your ms. ;)
2 replies · active 668 weeks ago
Don't you worry, I did cut that sucker down by more than half in my revision. I still cringe when I think of having queried it. I suppose there are worse things I could have done. I could have gotten a mullet right before my prom, for example. Or a tattoo of Billy Idol.
Impressive! Cutting can be sooooo hard.

Post a new comment

Comments by